← Back to Masjid As-SahabahView source post

What is Namimah?

6 November 2026 • 4.91K views
Sheikh Daghash Al-Ajmi hafidhahullah states: It (Namimah) is passing information between people with the intention of causing corruption and discord between them. This is called forbidden tale-carrying. Passing information between people with what intention? The intention of causing discord. However, if someone passes information between people with the intention of reconciling them, this is good tale-carrying, and it falls under the permissible and legislated forms of reconciliation. As for passing information with the intention of causing corruption and discord, this is forbidden tale-carrying. The Prophet ﷺ said: “A tale-carrier will not enter Paradise.” In another wording, the term Qattat (one who carries tales) is used, as mentioned in the two authentic collections (Sahih Al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim). This is therefore one of the major sins. What is the connection between tale-carrying and magic? What is the intended purpose of magic? To cause separation, as Allah says: “They learn from them that by which they cause separation between a man and his wife.” What does the tale-carrier want? Separation. For this reason, it is reported from Yahya ibn Aktham that he said: “The tale-carrier is worse than the magician. A tale-carrier can accomplish in one hour what a magician cannot accomplish in a year.” Why is the tale-carrier worse than the magician? A magician may sometimes exert great effort trying to bewitch someone and cause separation between him and his wife, or between him and other people, yet he may be unable to achieve this. For example, a person may frequently remember Allah, hold firmly to Allah, and hardly ever neglect his regular acts of worship and remembrance. The magician may therefore sit for a month, two months, three months or even a whole year, trying to affect him. But the tale-carrier comes along and, in just one hour, says: “May Allah forgive so-and-so! Yesterday, he spoke badly about you in a gathering. He said such-and-such about you.” By the following morning, that person may have severed his relationship with his brother. Or a man or woman may approach a woman and say: “Your husband does such-and-such. I saw him myself. I'm only telling you because I want what is good for you.” Yet sometimes this person hardly even knows the woman. As a result, she cuts off her relationship with her husband, and divorce takes place between them. The cause of all this is that piece of information which was conveyed through tale-carrying. Alternatively, a man may turn another man against his wife through tale-carrying, causing the relationship between them to break down. This happens frequently among people. Even those who are known for righteousness are affected by it. You may find students of knowledge developing resentment, hostility and hatred towards one another because of tale-carrying. Sometimes people even approach a Shaykh and cause corruption between him and his students. They say: “So-and-so and so-and-so, who are among your students, do such-and-such and say such-and-such.” The Shaykh then fails to investigate the matter. He does not ask questions, verify the information or establish whether it is true. Instead, he abandons those students and cuts off relations with them. As a result, they become alienated from him. What is particularly strange, brothers, is that sometimes you may have a companion whom you have known for ten or even twenty years, yet you find yourself abandoning him. You have a companion of twenty years, but you cut off relations with him because of something said to you by a man whom you have only known for a few months or a year! How can you believe someone whom you have known for just one year concerning a man with whom you have had a relationship for twenty years? Throughout those twenty years, did you not get to know him? Did you not observe him and establish what kind of person he was? And now this newcomer comes along and investigates him and reveals his true character to you? This is nothing but one of the ways Shaytan manipulates people. There are countless stories and accounts of the consequences of tale-carrying and how it causes separation between people. This is why tale-carrying is one of the major sins: because it causes corruption among people. It can ruin the relationship between a man and his wife, his brothers, his children, his relatives, his friends and his neighbours. Sometimes hostility develops between people, and someone abandons you without you even knowing why. You find yourself wondering: “Why has so-and-so abandoned me?” You try to contact him, but he continues to avoid you and does not even want to sit with you. Then, after a year or two, you discover that he abandoned you because someone had conveyed a statement to him and stirred up trouble between you. Where is brotherhood for the sake of Allah? Why not simply approach me and raise the matter with me? Say: “I have an issue with you. You said such-and-such.” I can then tell you whether I said it or not. If I say that I did not say it, then the matter is finished. If I say that I did say it, you can ask me: “Why did you say that?” And I can explain to you why I said it. But to simply abandon someone and sever the relationship between you without doing any of this is undoubtedly one of the ways Shaytan manipulates people. A sensible person does not accept what others say about his brothers in Islam, his relatives or his family members without proper verification. Someone you do not even know contacts you and says: “By Allah, so-and-so said such-and-such!” And you respond by abandoning that person. Allahul-Musta'an! (Allah is the One whose help is sought.) The Shaytan has played with you! You have now become one of the easiest people for Shaytan to manipulate. He comes to you through a complete stranger, who conveys some information about a man whom you already know, trust and have accepted as a companion. And you believe this stranger? This is foolishness and ignorance. You must be extremely strict when it comes to accepting reports and information. Is that not so? Who are you? The person says: “I'm only someone who wants what is good.” If you truly wanted what was good, you would not have carried tales between people. Rather, you are a wicked and sinful person! It is reported from Sufyan – I believe it was Sufyan Ath-Thawri – that a man once conveyed some information to him. He said: “I do not accept what you say, because you are a wicked person (faasiq).” The man asked: “How do you know that I am wicked?” He replied: “Because you engage in tale-carrying, and a tale-carrier will not enter Paradise.” Therefore, what are you? You are a faasiq (a wicked sinner). That is the end of the matter. A person should not allow himself to become a laughingstock or a plaything in the hands of such people. For this reason, it was appropriate for the author, may Allah have mercy upon him, to mention tale-carrying among the different types of magic, because perhaps it is one of the most widespread forms of magic. May Allah protect us and you from it. Source: https://t.me/masjidsahabah/2616