Practical demonstration:
20 June 2024 • 4.2K views
Based on the above differences, it may be said that "sample 1" comes under permissible Inshaad, while "sample 2" falls under forbidden Nasheed. والله أعلم
I asked Sheikh Ḥasan Bā Shu'aib ḥafidhahullāh about "Sample 2" and he affirmed that it falls under Nasheed.
Sheikh Muḥammad Hishām Aṭ- Ṭāhiri said regarding "Sample 2":
الصوتيات المصاحبة مما يسمى بالمؤثرات الصوتية محرمة
The accompanying sounds, commonly referred to as "sound effects", are prohibited.