BENEFIT 176: Why we should avoid taking knowledge from Muhammad Sa'eed Raslan | Abu Fajr Abdul Fattah حفظه الله
31 May 2024 • 2.62K views
0:01:05 - He has an unclear background in terms of who he studied with
0:02:30 - Those who've known him for years have stated that he was not cultivated upon Salafiyyah
0:09:02 - Sheikh Husein Al-Hateebi mentions some observations:
A. He takes advantage of foreign students via his institute and charity organisation (Al-Furqan)
B. He has a foul tongue
C. He doesn't allow students to teach at his institute except for a few
D. He became prominent after the fall of Usamah Al-Qoosi
0:19:11 - Examples of his foul speech
0:22:00 - Accuses his opponents of Haddadiyyah
0:24:40 - He is accused of plagiarism in some of his works
0:28:20 - He warns against listening to slang, yet in some of his rants he uses the foulest of slang
0:34:00 - he quotes from the likes of Sayyid Qutb in some of his works
0:36:08 - he quotes weak/fabricated narrations and may add extra phrases that are not part of the original ḥadīth
0:38:50 مجنون ليلى
0:39:40 - he recanted from some of his mistakes, such as
شاءت الأقدار
But at other times 0:40:00, he defends his mistakes.
-He may even insult the scholars 1:03:55 who criticise his mistakes
0:44:15 - he uses inappropriate phrases when speaking about some of the Companions
- example 0:46:35 (he has an unclear recantation regarding this)
- example 0:59:24 (umar)
- example 1:09:00 (Ansar)
- example 1:10:00
0:50:50 - clarifying the false belief concerning the Qur'ān is a reason for the Ummah to fall behind
- something similar here regarding Tawheed 1:00:30
0:55:49 - usage of incorrect terms
- 0:56:25 absolute freedom
- 1:03:56 time stopped
- 1:08:10 ghayb al-mutlaq
- He has some negative speech towards some of the Prophets
A. Musa peace be upon him 0:57:32
B. The Prophet bitten by an ant 1:02:10
1:05:15 - accuses specific individuals of being from the dogs of Hellfire
1:11:50 - Inappropriate speech against some of the Muslim rulers