Sheikh Hasan comments: He is calling towards blindfollowing of the madh-habs
28 May 2024 • 2.31K views
6. نحن لا نرد على أحد، لأن المقالات لا تتعلق بالرجال، والرجال يتغيرون...ولكن يوجه الرد للمقالات.
We do not refute individuals, because erroneous ideologies/statements are not about the people who make them, and people change...but rather, the refutation is directed at the ideologies themselves.
Sheikh Hasan comments: This means, don't mention people's names
نصحّح ولا نجرّج
"Correct [the mistake] without disparaging" - Refute the ideology, but don't refute the proponents!
7. لا تسألوا عن الناس سواء تصريحا أو تلميحا.
Do not inquire about individuals, whether explicitly or implicitly.
Sheikh Hasan comments: Don't enquire about the condition of Al-Qardhawi, but only ask about his erroneous statements...
8. المخالفة في الجزئي لا تخرج عن السنة ولو كان مشتهرا.
Opposing a secondary principle [of the religion] does not remove one from the Sunnah, even if it (the principle) is widely known.
If the intent here is that opposition of secondary principles does not remove one from Salafiyyah whatsoever, then this is incorrect. https://t.me/almanhajussalafi/70
Sheikh Hasan comments: If we apply this, then everyone would be considered to be Salafi except those with major deviations like the Jahmiyyah, the Rafidha, and so on from these major deviant sects.
٠ These are some of the erroneous statements of Al-Usaymi. So, do you want us to remain silent without clarifying them and warning others?!
٠ I was informed by someone who was there that most of the attendees are hizbees and members of charity organisations (jam'iyyaat). Why is that? Because they find what they covet within his gatherings; these erroneous principles.
٠ The fact that he is among the members of the council of major scholars is not enough, because even Abdullah Al-Mutlaq, who Sheikh Fawzan described to be an Ihkhwani, is a member of the same council.