Then he cites evidence that does not support his claim. Mariyah Al-Qibtiyyah, may Allah have mercy on her and be pleased with her, was a slave girl belonging to

Yet he makes women’s private parts permissible through such an ugly specious argument. Had he referred to the closest references among Muslims, he would have found that the meaning of right-hand possession is possession of a slave, and that it was a slave. Such an issue does not require much refutation, because if you asked any Muslim: “What is the meaning of right-hand possession?” he would say: “Male and female slaves.” Any Muslim who knows Arabic and understands this topic. Then this man comes and mixes things up. Perhaps what he has encountered is due to this. If anyone has engaged in anything based on such a fatwa—Allah forbid—it is indeed adultery, and the one who engaged in it must repent from it. Yahya Silmi must repent to Allah from issuing fatwas to people allowing this, making women’s private parts permissible without any evidence in the Book, the Sunnah, reasoning, consensus, or any indication. It is merely desire and ignorance of what Allah and His Messenger intended. Let him fear Allah, issue a statement retracting his previous words, and publish it. {Except those who repent, reform, and make clear—those I will accept their repentance.} If he persists in this after knowing the truth, I fear, by Allah, that it may lead to heresy, as he makes the private parts of free Muslim women permissible through an ugly specious argument with no evidence from the Book of our Lord, the Sunnah of our Prophet, nor sound nature, nor reason. I say this not as an argument based on reason and sound nature alone, apart from evidence from the Book and Sunnah, but I say this because this is a matter that none of the Muslim scholars have said—that right-hand possession means a man can give his daughter to whomever he wishes to enjoy her, have intercourse with her, be alone with her, travel with her, and she would be subject to the rulings of slavery and marriage. There is no power nor strength except with Allah. He claims he wants chastity for women, yet he seeks their ruin and the violation of the sanctities of Allah. There is no power nor strength except with Allah. We will stop here. Glory be to You, O Allah, and with Your praise. There is no god but You. I seek Your forgiveness and repent to You. May Allah reward you with good. Source: الفَتْحُ الرَّبَّانِي بِبَيانِ ضلالاتِ وكذِباتِ يحيى سِلْمِي السَّيْلانِي