Is Salafiyyah the asl (default state) of a Muslim?
No, it is INCORRECT to affirm Salafiyyah as the default state of a Muslim. If a person is Muslim, we affirm for them Islām and As-Salāmah (a state of innocence & blamelessness), but we do not automatically affirm Salafiyyah for them until they adhere to Salafiyyah; because 'Salafiyyah' is a praiseworthy description that is additional to Islām.
Imām Al-Barbahāri rahimahullāh said: “It is not permissible for a Muslim to say, 'so-and-so is a person of Sunnah' until he knows from him that he has combined the Khisāl (fundamental principles) of the Sunnah. It is not permissible to say about him 'a person of Sunnah' until he combines all of the [fundamental principles of the] Sunnah.” [https://t.me/youssefalgazairi/244]
Likewise, Sheikhul Islām Ibn Taymiyyah rahimahullāh said:
“As for the saying of those who say: The origin in Muslims is justice, then this is false, rather the origin in the humankind is transgression and ignorance, as He the Exalted said (in what is translated to mean): {But mankind bore it. Verily, he is transgressive and ignorant}. And mere utterance of the two testimonies (Shahādah) does not remove a person from the state of transgression and ignorance into a state of justice.”Majmū’ Al-Fatāwā (15/357)
Similarly, we do not affirm Salafiyyah for anyone by mere utterance of the Shahādah.
Sheikh ’Abdul-Azīz Ar-Rājihī hafidhahullāh commented on the above statement saying:
“The speech of Sheikhul Islām Ibn Taymiyyah is what is correct. He inferred and supported that based on evidence, and if a claim is backed and proven by clear evidence, it is to be accepted.”
Similarly, Sheikh Rabī’ ibn Hādi Al-Madkhali waffaqahullah said:
“How can the 'Sunnah' be the origin of people when we have Rafidites, we have Bātiniyyah (esotericists), we have communists, we have Hizbīs, and we have all kinds!! How can the origin in them be the Sunnah?!! [Who said] this statement!!? Meanwhile, Ibn Taymiyyah rahimahullāh refutes those who say: “The origin of a Muslim is justice/uprightness.” He says: This is a false statement, because Allāh Almighty said about mankind: {He is transgressive and ignorant}. Thus, the origin is transgression and ignorance ... meaning, his mere acceptance of Islām does not warrant him the rank of justice/uprightness. Or as he said. So how can the origin of people be the Sunnah in countries where the different sects are mixed together and where most people are not upon the Sunnah!?... If you know this [individual] is from a specific Salafi school, you have good assumption of him...We think well of him...
As for [generalising] even though the world is mixed-up and you cannot distinguish this one from that one, [then this is incorrect]. You need to determine who the people of truth are...That is why they (the Salaf) used to say, 'This knowledge is Deen, so look from whom you take your Deen.' But according to the view of those who say the origin of people is Sunnah, that would mean, take it (knowledge) from every Tom, Dick and Harry...Ibn Sīrīn said: 'The people never used to enquire about the isnād (chain of narration) but when the Fitnah occurred...(and the Fitnah during that time was not as bad as it is now)...They said name for us your men, and if he was from the people of the Sunnah, his hadith was accepted, but if he was from the people of innovation, his hadith was rejected.”
[From the tape (لقاء مع أهل اليمن)]
Source:
https://alilmia.com/vb/forum/%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%AC%D8%…
Question: Is the default condition of a Muslim adherence to the Sunnah or innovation? May Allah reward you with goodness.
Sheikh Yahya Al-Hajuri hafidhahullāh:
It cannot be said that all Muslims are adherents of the Sunnah, nor can it be said that all Muslims are adherents of innovation. Each individual must be assessed according to their own condition, and judgments should be made based on their current state. Among Muslims are some who follow the Sunnah, others are Sufis, some are Shia, some belong to political groups, and some hold Murji'ah beliefs. To label all these groups as adherents of the Sunnah is a grave error. Supporting this position is the saying of the Prophet ﷺ: "The Jews split into seventy-one sects, and the Christians split into seventy-two sects, and this Ummah will split into seventy-three sects, all of which will be in the Fire except one." This indicates that within this Ummah, which is the nation of response and reward, there are those who deviate from the saved group and from the truth and the Sunnah. [Al-Kanz Ath-Thameen]